- What two things should happen in the round before the aff. gives this speech?
- What is the aff. doing in this speech? Why is important for him/her to watch time?
- What is a "dropped" argument? What should you do with it?
- What does it mean to "extend" an argument? Does this give the debater an automatic win? Besides extending, what two things must be done with it?
- True or False: Answer your opponents arguments to your case by restating your original argument. Defend your answer.
Sunday, July 29, 2007
Rebuttal Speeches-1AR: pp. 35-37
Click on "comments" below to post your thoughts on the following:
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
1.) cross-ex and prep time before making the 1AR
2.) the aff attacks the neg and defends their own case; watch time b/c there is only four minutes to cover both sides
3.) a dropped argument is an argument your opponent doesn't address at the first chance; these are assumed to be true then and should be linked to the C and impacted why it's important
4.) extending is using the dropped argument for supporting your own V or C, and asks the judge to keep considering the argument during the round. this isn't an automatic win; it must be weighed and impacted in order to matter in the round
5.)false: you should explain why the answer is wrong or doesn't answer your argument.
1)The two things that should happen before the aff gives a speech is cx and prep.
2)*In this speech the aff is making sure that recovered their case and attacking the negs; in other words saying why they should win
*They should watch the time since there is only 4 minutes to take care of both.
3)*A dropped argument is when your opponent doesn't address one of your arguments after it is made.
*If an argument is dropped you should extend it.
4)*To extend an argument you are re-explaining your previous argument and asking the judge to keep considering the argument during the round.
*No this doesn't dive the debater an automatic win.
*Besides extending it must be weighed and impacted.
5)False-you would want to explain either why doesn't answer your argument or why their answer to your argument is wrong.
1)Before the 1 Ar, Cross ex and prep time should be used by the aff.
2)The aff is defending his own case and attacking the negative constructive.
3)Time is very important because the 1 AR is very important and is only 4 min long.
4) A dropped argument is one that is made but the opponent fails to respond to.
5)When an argument is dropped, the debator should tell the judge and give warrent and impact, and relate it to the V and VC.
6)This is by no means an automatic win. It may help ONLY if done correctly.
7)Not only must ti be extended, but it must be related to the value and value criterion.
8)FALSE debate is not just repeating the same answers over and over. That would b stupid. In rebutals we find flaws in our opponent's responces to our arguments. That is Db8! ;-)
1.Before 1ar, cross-ex and prep time usually take place.
2.in the 1ar, the aff is defending their case and responding to the neg arguments. watch your time b/c you only have 4 min to address both the neg and aff cases and responses
3.a dropped argument is one that was not responded to in the first opportunity to do so. you need to connect the dropped argument to the criterion for it to be useful
4.to extend an argument means to continue using the argument after it has been dropped or not attacked properly. you do this to show the judge that it should still be considered a useful argument in the round. it is not an automatic win if you extend an argument. with an extended argument you still need to show the judge how it links to the VP and C
5.false, you would want to explain why the answer is incorrect
-Cross-ex and prep time.
-You attack the neg. case first followed by the defending of the aff. case. Remember to watch time because you only have 4 minutes to handle both of these tasks.
-An argument that hasn't been brought up by your opponent or one that's been insufficiently argued against. You should bring attention to the fact that the argument was dropped and how that makes your argument even stronger because the point could not be crippled.
-You extend an argument by further elaborating on it when it is dropped. Not an auto win, but you do have to make sure the argument is weighed and impacted.
-False, explain why it doesn't work not just what your original point was. Show how the counter attack doesn't apply as much as your first statement.
-befoe the 1AR there will be cross-ex and prep time.
-during the 1AR the aff should first address the neg's case (arguing against the responses made by the neg), then you'll have to indicate to your judge that you are moving on the aff case (respond to the arguments made by the neg). Also don't forget to stay in order and it is also crucial to point out dropped arguments along the way (this can be a major help in winning the case).
-a dropped argument is an argument that wasn't answered by your opponent.
-you should alwasy point out to the judge when going through the case that an argument was dropped, this could help you win the round because they have no arguments against it. (but still remember to explain why your vp, criterion, or argument that was dripped is better or true in the case even if they drop it or it does not matter!!!)
-to "extnd" an argument means asking the judge to continue this argument throughout the round. to do so you must show its importance for the roudn by explaining to judge the argument itsself(or claim) and the warrant and impact it has on the round.
-this does not give the debator an automatic win they must still prove it throughout the case and ecplain it in the final speech for it to be valid at all.
- it must be linked back to the vp and criterion for it have any meaning in the debate
-false: you need to explain why it is flawd and why it doesn't answer the original argument.
Post a Comment